Thursday, September 5, 2013

Baby Messiah Name Change

This week, we have been talking a lot about the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. Reading and hearing about the amendments and the original Constitution made me remember a news story from Tennessee about a judge forcibly changing a baby boy's name from Messiah to Martin, because, according to the judge, there is only one individual deserving of that title. I have several problems with this decision.This judge asserted her own religious beliefs into a very personal and private matter, the naming of one's child, which I think a judge should have had no say in to begin with. She went against the ideas and rights of Freedom of Speech and the Separation of church and state, both key parts of the Constitution, and at the same time, she violated the very basic rights of that child's parents. A parent should be able to name their children whatever they want, and the government should have no say whatsoever in it. This judge violated those parents' first amendment rights to freedom of speech by restricting what they could name their children, and the right to the government not pushing religious beliefs onto its citizens by basing her decision solely on her personal religious beliefs. While I may not agree with the parents' choice of a name, I believe that they should at least have that opportunity to name their child what they want, without any level of government interfering.

1 comment:

  1. Wow. That is the only thing I could think of when I read this. I remember the uproar over this case. I find this so absurd and want to find the judge and tell him about how his life choices are just wrong. All of them. Wrong.
    First of all, this is none of his business and I have to ask how he even got this thorough enough people to get it to this progressed stage within our law system. I also would like to ask where this idea came from? Who in his life had told him that he had had any such power to tell other people that they can't name their child what they want? Sure he can disagree but don't these law officials have to go through some kind of training at some point to learn how the law and legal system works?

    ReplyDelete